The World's Finest Luxury Rail Journeys ☎ 1-800-724-5120 travel@palacetours.com
Home / Journal / Heritage
Heritage

George Pullman and the American Palace Car

Sleeping cars had run in America for 26 years before Pullman built the Pioneer; what he actually invented was the rule that no railway was allowed to own one.

Sleeping cars had been running in Pennsylvania since 1839, when the Cumberland Valley Railroad put two partitioned berth cars named Chambersburg and Carlisle into service between Harrisburg and Chambersburg. George Mortimer Pullman was eight years old. By the time he built the Pioneer in 1865, the sleeping car was a quarter of a century old and thoroughly unglamorous. What Pullman invented was not the bed on wheels but the proposition that the railway should not be allowed to own it.

That distinction explains almost everything that followed: a fleet of nearly ten thousand cars that belonged to no railroad, a company town outside Chicago, the strike that broke it, and a proper noun that crossed the Atlantic and quietly changed meaning. In Britain a Pullman is not a bed at all. It is a chair, a table, a lamp and lunch, and you can still sit in one.

A first that was not first

Pullman was born on 3 March 1831 at Brockton, New York, and made his first money moving buildings: from 1857 he was among the contractors jacking Chicago bodily out of the mud so a sewer system could be laid beneath it. The work taught him that people pay handsomely for an ordeal made to feel like nothing at all.

The Pioneer was built in 1865 in the Chicago and Alton Rail Road shed that stood where Union Station stands today. It had red carpet, hand-finished woodwork and silver-trimmed coal lamps, and it was wider and taller than the cars around it. Sources put its cost at either $18,000 or $20,000; both figures come from Pullman institutions. At a time when a conventional coach was an unupholstered box, it was an absurd sum, and the car sat largely idle.

What actually happened after Lincoln died

Every account of Pullman's rise pivots on the same scene: the funeral train, the nation watching, the new sleeper suddenly famous. The train is well documented. The Lincoln Special ran nine cars, carried some three hundred mourners and covered 1,654 miles through 180 cities and seven states.

The Pioneer's part in it is where the sources part company. The Smithsonian and the University of Illinois's Lincoln collections record that the car was selected for the final leg and that every station and bridge between Chicago and Springfield had to be cut back to clear its width. The Pullman History Site is more modest: Colonel James H. Bowen chose the car to carry the Lincoln family. Railway researchers and a Cornell University Press study of the Pullman family are sceptical of both, treating the dramatic version — coffin aboard, a continent of platforms rebuilt overnight — as publicity the company generated years later, once it had an interest in a founding legend.

The likeliest truth is the unglamorous one: the Pioneer ran in one of the trains carrying family and dignitaries from Chicago to Springfield, and did not carry the coffin. That was enough. Illinois turned out in enormous numbers, and the car was in it.

The invention was the balance sheet

The Pullman Palace Car Company was chartered by the Illinois legislature on 22 February 1867, and its radical feature was contractual. Pullman did not sell cars. He built them, kept them, staffed them and leased them complete with crew, taking the supplementary fare from the passenger. The railway supplied the locomotive and the track; Pullman supplied the experience and controlled it absolutely — the linen, the food, the service standard, the name on the flank of the car.

It worked because it made quality enforceable: no railroad could dilute a Pullman to save money, because no railroad owned one. By the 1920s the company ran around 9,800 cars staffed by some 10,500 porters, attendants and maids. It was the largest hotel operation in the world, and it had no buildings.

The restaurant that never paid for itself

Beds were only half of it. In 1867 came the first hotel car, the President, a sleeper with a kitchen attached, which freed trains from the depot lunch stop. A year later came the Delmonico, named without modesty after the Manhattan restaurant: sixty feet long, two cooks, four waiters in white jackets, seats for forty-eight. Dining cars almost never made money, then or since. They sold the sleeper. That the restaurant is a loss leader for the bedroom still underwrites gastronomy on luxury trains.

  • 1839 — The Cumberland Valley Railroad runs America's first sleeping cars, built by Philip Imlay of Philadelphia.
  • 1865 — The Pioneer is completed in Chicago.
  • 1867 — The company is chartered on 22 February; the hotel car President enters service.
  • 1874 — The first Pullman car runs in Britain, on the Midland Railway.
  • 1887 — The Sessions vestibule makes walking between cars safe.
  • 1894 — The Pullman strike begins on 11 May.
  • 1968 — Pullman sleeping-car operations cease on 31 December.

The town that was also a wage

In 1880 Pullman bought 4,000 acres near Lake Calumet, fourteen miles south of Chicago, for $800,000, and built a town: housing, shops, a library, a church, a hotel named Florence after his eldest daughter. It was one of the first planned industrial communities in the United States, and it was also a mechanism: workers rented from the company that paid them. When the depression of 1893 arrived, the company cut wages by a quarter and more, and did not cut rents.

On 11 May 1894 the workforce walked out; the American Railway Union under Eugene V. Debs refused to handle Pullman cars, and within days some 125,000 workers on twenty-nine railroads had joined. Federal troops ended it. Pullman died on 19 October 1897 and was buried in a grave lined with concrete and reinforced with steel rails, on the assumption that someone would try to dig him up.

The company's other legacy was less intended. Pullman hired formerly enslaved men as porters and became the largest employer of Black Americans in the country. In August 1925 they organised as the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters under A. Philip Randolph and Milton P. Webster, and in 1937 signed the first agreement between a major American corporation and a Black-led union.

How the word changed meaning at sea

Pullman cars reached Britain in 1874, shipped as kits and assembled at the Midland Railway's Derby works — thirty-seven before the contract lapsed in 1888. The sleeping cars flopped. Britain is too small; nobody needs a bed between London and Manchester. So the Pullman Car Company reinvented itself around the daylight journey, selling the armchair, the table lamp and the meal served at your elbow, and in British usage a Pullman has meant a first-class day saloon ever since. The London, Brighton and South Coast Railway ran the first complete Pullman train in 1881, and control passed into British hands under Lord Dalziel in 1905. The Brighton Belle, renamed from the Southern Belle in 1934, was the world's only all-electric all-Pullman service and ran until 30 April 1972; the Golden Arrow carried passengers toward Dover and onward to Paris. Georges Nagelmackers was meanwhile building the European answer on a continent large enough to want beds.

Sitting in the argument

The British side of the story is still rolling. The carriages of the British Pullman are the genuine articles: Ibis, built in 1925, sold to Wagons-Lits for Italian service and bought back in 1928 for the Golden Arrow; Zena of 1928, which worked the Queen of Scots and the Yorkshire Pullman; Perseus, part of Churchill's funeral train in 1965. They are the last working evidence of what the word came to mean here.

The same rake forms the British leg of the Venice Simplon-Orient-Express, where Pullman's model and Nagelmackers' meet on one itinerary — day saloon to the coast, sleeping car beyond it; the resemblances are worth tracing across the trains that carry the name. Elsewhere the principle of owning and staffing the whole train survives intact, on the Royal Scotsman and the other luxury trains of Britain and Scotland, and on Rovos Rail, whose founder restored his own carriages for Pullman's reason exactly. A survey of the surviving fleets is a survey of one accounting idea.

Related
Enquire With Our Concierge More from the Journal

Palace Tours is a service of TravBuzz Inc. · Fla. Seller of Travel Reg. No. ST41461